At Tenant CS, we sit on the tenant's side of rent negotiations, and a market rent review is one of the clauses that trips up tenants. The difference between a 'face' and an 'effective' market rent review can make a significant difference to your bottom line, so it pays to know which one your lease uses before you exercise an option or sign a new deal.
Most tenants only deal with a market rent review once every few years. The landlord's agent deals with them all the time. Understanding how the process works, and where the traps are, puts you in a much stronger position.
A market rent review is a lease clause that resets your rent to the current market rate at an agreed point, usually when you exercise an option to renew or partway through a long lease. Unlike a fixed or CPI review, the new rent isn't known in advance; it's negotiated, and if the parties can't agree, it may be decided by an independent valuer.
Most commercial leases with an option to renew include a market rent review clause. The exact process depends on your lease, but it generally works like this:
On option reviews, many leases require you to commit to the new term before the new rent is set. That means you may not know exactly what you'll pay before you decide to stay, which is one reason we look closely at the review clause before a client exercises an option.
It depends on your lease. Market rent reviews most commonly apply when a tenant exercises an option to renew, regardless of the length of the lease. Longer leases may also include a mid-term market review, for example five years into a 10-year lease. If you're considering extending early, a blend and extend negotiation can be an alternative to waiting for a review.
The type of review in your lease can make a big difference to the outcome. These terms build on the definitions of net, gross, face and effective rent, but here's how they apply to a review:
Landlords tend to favour face reviews.

Here's a simplified example to show why the type of review matters. All figures are hypothetical and for illustration only, not market benchmarks, and exclude GST and outgoings.
Assume a tenant occupies 400 sqm and exercises an option with a market rent review. Comparable new leases are being agreed at a face rent of $650/sqm net, with a 25% incentive.

This is a simplified illustration assuming the full 25% market incentive is reflected in the reviewed rent. In practice, the treatment of incentives depends on the lease wording, the structure of comparable transactions and the valuation methodology, which is why it's worth getting advice before you respond to a review notice.
Tenant tip: Check whether your review clause is 'face' or 'effective' before you sign the lease, not when the review notice arrives. It's much easier to negotiate the clause upfront than to argue about it later.
We generally advise our clients to negotiate an effective market rent review, both in new leases and when weighing up whether to exercise an option. Here's why:
It's also worth remembering that exercising an option and negotiating a new lease are not the same thing. Exercising an option generally means accepting the existing lease conditions, including how market rent is reviewed. Negotiating a new lease with your current landlord may provide an opportunity to secure a fresh incentive and more favourable terms, rather than relying on the existing review mechanism.
Although the process is fairly standard, negotiating a market rent review isn't always straightforward. Here are the traps we see most often.
Many leases give the landlord a long window to issue a market rent review notice, which allows them to time it for the best outcome. Tenants, on the other hand, can have a short time to respond: in some leases, as little as 14 days. Notices issued around holiday periods can make that window even tighter.
The review can also extend into the new lease term, so you may only find out the new rent after you've committed to staying. If you don't have the market evidence ready to respond, the rent may end up being determined by a valuer, which can be costly.
In many leases, if you don't respond within the set timeframe, you're taken to have accepted the landlord's proposed rent.
Tenant tip: Diarise every review date and response deadline as soon as you sign.
A landlord may propose a high rent, knowing the tenant will dispute it, in the hope that the negotiation ends somewhere above market. Or, in a flat market, the landlord may propose what looks like a small increase, say 4% to 5%, in the hope that the tenant won't think it's worth disputing.
Some leases include a ratchet clause, which prevents the rent from going down on review even if the market has fallen. If your lease has one, make sure you understand how it affects your review before you exercise an option, and get your own legal advice if you're unsure.
Tenant tip: Don't accept a proposed increase just because it looks small. Get market evidence first: even a modest overstatement adds up over a five-year term.
.jpg)
We work only for tenants, so our job is to make sure your rent reflects the real market, not the landlord's preferred number. Whether you're negotiating a new lease, exercising an option or responding to a review notice, we can review your clause, gather the market evidence and handle the negotiation from start to finish. For any terms you're not sure about, our commercial real estate terminology guide is a good place to start.
Book a call with us today to see how we can help you.
A market rent review is a lease clause that resets your rent to the current market rate, usually when you exercise an option to renew or partway through a long lease. The landlord proposes a new rent, the tenant can accept or dispute it, and if the parties can't agree, many leases allow an independent valuer to determine it.
A face rent review sets the new rent at the headline market rate, ignoring incentives such as rent-free periods and fit-out contributions. An effective rent review takes those market incentives into account, which generally results in a lower rent where incentives are being offered. Landlords tend to prefer face reviews, so tenants should check which type their lease uses.
An open market rent review sets the rent by reference to what a willing tenant would pay a willing landlord for similar premises in the open market at the review date. The exact assumptions, such as whether incentives are included, depend on how the lease clause is worded, so it's worth having the clause reviewed before you sign.